A Taxonomy of Role Model’s Sallies

}

August 16, 2025

l

editor@creativeunderworld.com

Photo-Illustration: by The Cut; Photos: Getty Images

Justin Bieber had his “One Less Lonely Girl.” Charli XCX has her designated “Apple” dancer. Sabrina Carpenter has her fuzzy pink handcuffs. And now, the viral pop-concert trend filling everyone’s TikTok feeds is Role Model’s Sallies. Since his hit song “Sally, When The Wine Runs Out” dropped in February, Role Model — a.k.a. 28-year-old musician Tucker Pillsbury — has been inviting one lucky attendee onstage at each show to dance as that night’s titular Sally. If you’ve seen someone in cowboy boots bopping around on a stage in the past few months, chances are it was at a Role Model concert.

At first, the honor typically went to fans plucked straight from the crowd. But as the concert moment — and Role Model himself — started blowing up, the Sallies have become more varied, and also a lot more famous. Here are all the celebrities who’ve been Sally so far, from the A-listers to the ones you’re probably too old to know about.

The A-List

Kate Hudson (August 9: Aspen, Colorado)

Penny Lane, back in the flesh.

Natalie Portman (July 28: New York, New York)

While filming the rom-com Good Sex with Role Model, Natalie Portman joined her co-star as Sally at Madison Square Garden.

The Gen-Z Music Divas

Olivia Rodrigo (August 1: Chicago, Illinois)

Fresh off her performance with Weezer at Lollapalooza, Olivia Rodrigo returned to the stage as Sally.

Reneé Rapp (April 3: Los Angeles, California)

And she didn’t spill one drop of her White Claw.

Troye Sivan (August 8: San Francisco, California)

I feel the rush (of being Sally).

Conan Gray (June 6: Queens, New York)

He even wore a “Wish I Were Sally” tee for the occasion.

The Dare (July 31: Chicago, Illinois)

By my estimate, the first-ever Sally to wear a suit and tie.

María Zardoya (August 2: St. Charles, Iowa)

The lead singer of the Marías took on Sally duties at the Hinterland Music Festival in Iowa.

Ashe (March 8: Nashville, Tennessee)

The singer-songwriter was one of Role Model’s first celebrity Sallies in March.

Dylan Minnette (April 2: Los Angeles, California)

They wore matching outfits!

The Podcasters

Bowen Yang (April 28: New York, New York)

Bowen Yang made Las Culturistas listeners proud with his performance as Sally on The Tonight Show.

Jake Shane (February 27: Dallas, Texas)

TikTok star turned podcaster Jake Shane was the first-ever celebrity Sally, thanks to an inside joke among fans that the song is about him.

Grace O’Malley (March 12: Washington, D.C.)

Grace O’Malley — also a TikTok star turned podcaster — fully wiped out onstage, in a moment she swore was “not a bit.

Honorable Mention

Role Model’s mom (April 23: Boston, Massachusetts)

Mother Sally herself!

Related